A tale of two clerks
by Dan Furman on December 15, 2009
Well, two service people (one clerk, and one waiter.)
Yesterday, Maryellen and I went to the diner. We love the local diner here - really good food, very reasonable, and usually good service.
Tonight we go in, get seated and then… nothing. We had menus, and were ready to order, but a server never came. I guess the person who handled our section just wasn’t on the ball. I could see three waitresses talking, and I made eye contact, but nobody came. 5 minutes or so go by, and I’m ready to leave (I never complain about stuff like this - I just leave.)
The waiter handling the next table notices me reaching for my coat, and he says “nobody helped you?” to which I reply “no”. He sighed, looked over at the group of waitresses, and then said “nevermind, I’ll handle you guys”.
And he did - superbly. I tipped him $10 for a $20 check.
Part of the reason I tipped him so was because I really like that in any worker, in any profession. It’s how I am personally in any job I ever had. He saw a problem, and instead of passing it off, he took ownership of it. He didn’t worry about “they don’t pay me enough” or “that’s not my area” or whatever. He saw a problem that was solvable by him, and he solved it. People like that will go far in life.
Then today, I had the exact opposite experience.
I go to Lowes (a home improvement store for those that don’t know.) I needed a new shop-vac for the garage. I go to the display, and figure the 12 Gallon one would suffice. But there aren’t any there… there’s a hole where the boxes for this model should be. I look up, and waaaay on the top shelf (a good 20-30′ up) I see a bunch of them. In the next aisle, there’s one of those movable stairway/ladder type things that can be used to get these down. All I need is a clerk…
There are three within 20′ of me, all hanging out and talking. I approach and ask if someone could get me a shop vac down. They said they’d get someone. They call on the phone. 5 minutes go by, and nobody comes. I go back to the three, and ask again. One guy says “well, I called someone”, as if telling me that should satisfy me (it didn’t). Finally, I said “screw it” and went to the ladder myself and started to bring it over to the shop vac aisle - I’ll do this myself.
One of the three (the guy who “called” someone) sees what I am doing and runs over yelling “hey hey… don’t touch that” to which I said “well, I’m not waiting anymore - I’ll do it myself”. Clearly annoyed, he says “fine! I’ll do it” and grudgingly wheels the ladder over and gets me a shop vac.
So he brings it down and I say “why didn’t you just do that five minutes ago?” He just gives me “the look” and walks away, pissed because… I dunno. Because he had to work?
The contrast between these two service experiences is telling. One guy saw a problem and fixed it. The other got annoyed and essentially said “not my job”. I’ll bet almost anything that, regardless of where they end up, the waiter out-earns the Lowes guy ten times over during the next thirty years. People who solve problems are always in demand. People who hide are the first to get laid off.
Now, if you know me, you know I have had my problems with companies, etc. And I don’t advocate just doing all the work or staying late for the company, etc. But, despite how I’ve always felt about companies, I was also always a problem solver, and I admire that trait in others.
To me, this is a character issue, and is not something that can be taught - you either think this way, or you don’t.
Dan Furman is a professional writer, author, entrepreneur, business consultant, and all around good guy (so they say.)
December 16th, 2009 at 7:17 pm
I completely agree. I worked at a shop once where we worked on commission and once a clerk had “claimed” a customer they were supposed to be off limits. But some people were better at keeping the customers taken care of the whole time in the store than others. They would sometimes ignore people or stop asking them if they wanted to see things. It was really irritating to hear them complain when another clerk has “Stolen” their sale. Why didn’t the tend to their customer?